Paychex Flex vs Square Payroll
This comparison is for 10 employees, no contractors, and one state. It counts only plans that file payroll taxes. Only Square Payroll publishes a full-service total, at $95 a month.
Paychex Flex
Quote only. The compare page describes Paychex Flex and tells visitors to contact sales. No monthly or per-employee list price is published.
Quote only
No published full-service total for this team.
- Paychex Flex · quote
Square Payroll
Full-service payroll is $35 a month plus $6 per person paid. Contractor-only payroll is $6 per person paid, with no base fee. Tax filing for employees is included on the full-service plan.
$95
Full-service payroll · $1,140 / year at list price
- Full-service payroll · $35 + $6/employee
- Contractor-only payroll · $0 + $0/employee
Paychex Flex pricing 2026Square Payroll pricing 2026Recalculate for a different headcount
Questions
- Which is cheaper for 10 employees, Paychex Flex or Square Payroll?
- Only Square Payroll publishes a full-service total, at $95 a month on Full-service payroll.
- What do these totals include?
- The totals are list prices for 10 employees, no contractors, and one state, on plans that file payroll taxes. Introductory discounts are not applied.
Prices verified Nov 10, 2026 from vendor sites. Written by PayrollPriceWatch.
We may earn a commission if you sign up through a link on this site. That does not change the prices we show. Prices are checked weekly from each vendor's site.